Part of my job is to know a good icebreaker or two.
I tried a new one recently, and I messed it up. Or at least it felt that way in the moment.
The setup of the activity was simple. It involved participants writing down two questions they would ask, if they were getting to know someone new. That’s all I needed to explain.
I pride myself on being able to explain something clearly, and when I tried this time, I received only confused faces in return.
In moments like this, I lose a little trust in myself.
This was a very simple activity. Where had I gone wrong?
**
Josh Waitzkin was a chess prodigy before chess computers were a thing.
He had a manual method of studying the games he lost. This method would begin at the critical position from one of his games, where he realized that his intuition had come up short. He would start to think through variations, slowly sinking deeper and deeper into formal analysis.
In his book The Art of Learning, he writes, “Like a runner in stride, my thinking became unhindered, free-flowing, faster and faster as I lost myself in the position. Sometimes the study would take six hours in one sitting, sometimes thirty hours over a week.”
That’s the price Josh was willing to pay to find understanding. Eventually, the understanding that eluded him during a loss, found him during the analysis.
“I saw the best move, felt the correct plan, understood the evaluation of the position. I couldn’t explain this new knowledge with variations or words. It felt more elemental, like rippling water or a light breeze. My chess intuition had deepened.”
**
Dani DaOrtiz is the magician’s magician. If you watch one of his performances doing card magic (his preferred form), it looks like he is improvising the entire time. He is not. In an interview on the podcast Discourse in Magic, Dani explains that he is both improvising and not improvising.
He does this by studying a large number of variations for any given trick and making each variation part of his muscle memory. This effort makes his understanding so deep, that when it comes time for a show, he simply has to think of the name of a trick and his body intuitively knows what to do.
He calls this being spontaneous, not improvising. The beauty of Dani’s magic is his spontaneity, which is borne out of an effort to craft understanding into his muscles.
**
The problem with my explanation of the icebreaker, was that I tried to memorize it.
I wanted to say it a certain way (probably because I wanted to sound cool saying it), and so I wrote down exactly what I wanted to say and tried to repeat that to myself many times. In the end, it didn’t come out that way at all.
Memorizing something isn’t understanding it. It’s just knowing the name of it. Names are easily forgotten. Memorizing is cheap. Understanding has a cost.
The cost is the effort or experience required to let the thing sink into your bones. To let it become part of you.
It’s easier to trust yourself with something when you’ve borne the cost of understanding it.



